Money and shame

Money and Shame Pic

Money shame is real.

I had outlined this post when a dear friend sent me a text message. “Why do we go to the doctor when we’re sick, bring our car to the mechanic but we aren’t supposed to talk about money or ask for help when we have money questions?”

Money shame. Somewhere along the way, the notion that it is impolite to discuss finances has gone to an extreme where no one talks about money ever. Sure, it’s still impolite to ask someone how much money they make or how much something cost them, but what about the rest? What about those struggling with money? With budgeting? With debt? With savings? With retirement? Money is so complex and emotionally charged, it’s one of the top reasons for conflict in relationships and it causes stress in the lives of countless people. Its management is also critically important to your future and security. I’m going to talk money because I think financial literacy is important.

There are two MBAs living under our roof and neither of us had done a true written budget until last year. No matter how much education you have, there is very little exposure to managing your own personal finances. It’s not that we didn’t want to or that we weren’t smart enough, it was a combination of not knowing how, and for me, some shame. I read Dave Ramsey’s “Total Money Makeover” in three days while my husband was gone on a business trip. I opened my laptop, created our complete budget and when he came home, told him about our new plan. He was totally on board and excited (relieved?) that we had a path. I was so excited that I shared with a few close friends and family members. The responses were so interesting.

“Ohhhh, Jen. I’m so sorry. I thought you guys were doing okay . . . .”

FREEZE. Okay. This response, I will admit, sparked some shame. We WERE doing ok. We could pay all of our bills. We never worried about feeding our family. We were saving some. We were able to give gifts and have fun. We were fine. Why did a budget suddenly mean that we weren’t doing okay? Are budgets only for people who aren’t doing okay financially? “Doesn’t that feel too restrictive?” “Only poor people need to budget.” “Only people with a lot of money can budget.” “You work hard, you DESERVE to get whatever you want.” WOAH. No wonder we have money shame.

For a lot of people, money shame comes when you have to say no, when you limit, when you have to own up to your own financial behavior, when you spend money you know you don’t have, when you know you should be changing your behavior and don’t, or when you ask for help. It also prevents us from change. “I deserve,” “I earned,” “I want.” Disregarding our long-term for short-term gratification. Our focus culturally has shifted from being wise with money to materialism and the price is high. Any of this sound familiar?

I challenge you to let go of the shame. For so many reasons. The biggest is that shame weighs us down and gets in the way of happiness. It gets in the way of actually being able to help ourselves financially. Don’t let your shame rob your future. Saying no is hard, asking for help is hard, owning up to your behavior is hard, but once you do it, you’re free! You can go on the path. You can learn. You can grow. You can pay off debt, save and be financially secure. You can give. You can win.

The single best way to control your finances is to control what goes OUT. Get a written budget. “The Millionaire Next Door” teaches us that most millionaires become millionaires because they control what goes out. They don’t buy things they can’t afford. They save and invest. They are disciplined. They say no. And most of them did that from the ground up – not from inheritances or the lottery. Hard work and smart choices. They aren’t ashamed to limit themselves.

It’s something everyone can do…but you have to let go of the shame.

jensignature

Comments

  1. Carol says

    Impatiently waiting for a budget organization video & blog post! Your Instagram clip of your budget notebook was such a teaser! I’m excited for your future blog posts!

  2. Anna Schleimer says

    You couldn’t have said it better! The same thing happened when I started our budget, my mom asked if we were doing okay. After we got our taxes done this year we were kinda of shocked at how much we spent/made but had very little in savings or investments. Our budget wasn’t because we couldn’t make ends meet it was because we realized that for being in our mid 30’s we weren’t saving enough for our future and retirement. Budgeting gave our money a purpose!! So whatever the reasons that peoe budget, good for you for taking time to strategize about money and not just spend it! No shame in that 🙂

  3. Ann Crick says

    What gets me is when I say “I can’t afford that” or I really want that but I need to save for it” I get responses like… “Do you need me to send you some money”, ” Why didn’t you tell me you are having money problems” or my favourite ” maybe you should look at getting a different/better job” ( I work from home)

    What they aren’t getting is I don’t have money issues, my job pays me enough to pay bills keep a roof over my head and put food on the table. I’m following Dave Ramsey baby steps, I choose where my money goes and that is to get out of debt and have a fully funded emergency fund, not to buy that new dress or a lovely pair of heels, yes I will have those things, but only when if saved and can pay cash. If they aren’t then when I have saved then I wasn’t meant to have them and the money will go towards something else.

    Don’t always assume that when someone says they can’t afford something that they are struggling with money, they may just be allocating money to a more important place!!

Trackbacks

  1. […] Shame, guilt, and intimidation. Not all of us are here, but a lot of us are. Shame over our current situation, shame over what we may have done to get us here, shame over not pulling ourselves out sooner. Intimidation that you don’t know enough. You know what? Check it at the door. It’s hurting your financial life. I’m not discounting the feeling – it’s *very* real and it’s very impactful, which is why I want to challenge you to let go of it. It gets in the way of progress. No one became good with money overnight. No one was born with it. Just like everything else in life, we have to keep finding ways to learn about it so we get more comfortable with it and get better. Progress! To read more of my thoughts on money and shame, see this blog post. […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *